2018 Toyota Highlander Vs 2018 Honda Pilot

The mid-size SUV segment is fiercely competitive, and the 2018 Toyota Highlander and 2018 Honda Pilot represent two of the most popular choices. Both offer three-row seating, ample cargo space, and a reputation for reliability, making them attractive to families. However, beneath the surface similarities lie distinct engineering choices and performance characteristics that cater to different needs and preferences. This article delves into a technical comparison of these two models, analyzing their specifications, real-world performance, reliability, and maintenance considerations, and places them within the broader context of the evolving automotive landscape.

Powertrain and Performance: A Technical Comparison

The 2018 Toyota Highlander typically offers a choice between a 2.7-liter four-cylinder engine and a 3.5-liter V6. The four-cylinder, while more fuel-efficient, is generally considered underpowered for a vehicle of this size, especially when fully loaded. The 3.5-liter V6, producing around 295 horsepower and 263 lb-ft of torque, is the more desirable option. It's paired with an 8-speed automatic transmission, contributing to smooth acceleration and decent fuel economy. Toyota's engineering prioritizes reliability and longevity, sometimes at the expense of outright performance. The Highlander's suspension is tuned for comfort, providing a compliant ride that absorbs bumps effectively. All-wheel drive (AWD) is available, enhancing traction in adverse weather conditions.

The 2018 Honda Pilot is primarily powered by a 3.5-liter V6 engine, generating approximately 280 horsepower and 262 lb-ft of torque. Lower trims are equipped with a 6-speed automatic transmission, while higher trims benefit from a more advanced 9-speed automatic. This transmission, although offering more gears, has been known to have some reported issues with smoothness in earlier iterations. The Pilot's engine boasts Honda's VTEC (Variable Valve Timing and Lift Electronic Control) technology, optimizing engine performance across a wider RPM range. Honda tends to prioritize a more engaging driving experience, and the Pilot's steering feels more responsive than the Highlander's. Like the Highlander, AWD is available. The Pilot's suspension strikes a balance between comfort and handling, making it feel slightly more nimble on the road.

Engineering Choices and Drivetrain Analysis

Toyota's engineering philosophy often revolves around proven technology and meticulous quality control. The Highlander's V6 engine is a well-established powerplant, known for its durability. The 8-speed transmission is also generally reliable. Toyota's AWD system typically favors front-wheel drive under normal conditions, engaging the rear wheels when needed to maintain traction. The emphasis is on fuel efficiency and minimizing drivetrain losses.

Honda, on the other hand, frequently incorporates more innovative technologies. The Pilot's VTEC engine showcases this commitment to optimization. The 9-speed transmission, while offering theoretical advantages in fuel economy and performance, required more careful calibration. Honda's AWD system, often referred to as Intelligent Variable Torque Management (i-VTM4), can proactively distribute torque to individual wheels, enhancing handling and stability, particularly in challenging conditions. This system offers more sophisticated torque vectoring capabilities compared to the Highlander's simpler system.

Real-World Performance and Driving Experience

In real-world driving, the Highlander delivers a comfortable and composed ride. The V6 engine provides adequate power for most situations, and the 8-speed transmission shifts smoothly. However, the Highlander can feel a bit cumbersome in tight maneuvers due to its size and weight. Its steering is light and predictable, but lacks the precision of the Pilot. The Highlander excels at long-distance cruising, providing a quiet and refined cabin environment.

The Pilot offers a slightly more engaging driving experience. The V6 engine feels responsive, and the 9-speed transmission (in higher trims) provides quick and efficient shifts. The Pilot's steering is more communicative, allowing for greater driver confidence. While the ride is still comfortable, it's slightly firmer than the Highlander, resulting in better body control in corners. The Pilot's cabin is generally quiet, although some road noise may be noticeable at higher speeds.

Reliability, Maintenance, and Long-Term Ownership

Both the Highlander and Pilot have strong reputations for reliability. Toyota's reputation for bulletproof reliability is well-deserved, and the Highlander consistently scores well in reliability surveys. Routine maintenance is relatively straightforward and affordable. It's crucial to adhere to Toyota's recommended maintenance schedule, including oil changes, filter replacements, and fluid checks.

The Honda Pilot is also considered a reliable vehicle. However, there have been some reports of issues with the 9-speed transmission in earlier models, so it's important to check for any service bulletins or recalls related to the transmission. Like the Highlander, regular maintenance is essential for long-term reliability. Pay close attention to transmission fluid changes, as neglected maintenance can lead to transmission problems.

Pros and Cons: A Summary

2018 Toyota Highlander

Pros: Exceptional reliability, Comfortable ride, Smooth and quiet cabin, Strong resale value.

Cons: Less engaging driving experience, Four-cylinder engine is underpowered, Styling can be considered bland.

2018 Honda Pilot

Pros: More engaging driving experience, Spacious interior, Available advanced safety features, Innovative AWD system.

Cons: 9-speed transmission can be problematic, Ride can be slightly firmer, Styling may not appeal to everyone.

Alternatives

Other noteworthy alternatives in this segment include the Ford Explorer, Chevrolet Traverse, Mazda CX-9, and Kia Telluride (though the Telluride debuted shortly after this model year, so consider a slightly newer model). The Explorer offers a more powerful engine option and a sportier driving experience. The Traverse provides exceptional cargo space. The CX-9 boasts a stylish design and a refined interior. The Telluride (newer models) is praised for its value, features, and upscale interior.

Future Trends and Automotive Industry Outlook

The automotive industry is undergoing a rapid transformation, driven by electrification, autonomous driving, and connectivity. Hybrid and electric SUVs are becoming increasingly popular, offering improved fuel efficiency and reduced emissions. Advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) are also becoming more prevalent, enhancing safety and convenience. In the future, we can expect to see more electric and hybrid versions of the Highlander and Pilot, as well as more sophisticated ADAS features. The increasing importance of software and over-the-air updates will also play a crucial role in vehicle maintenance and performance.

The competition between Toyota and Honda, and indeed, the entire automotive industry, will continue to intensify as these technological advancements accelerate. The focus on sustainability and connectivity will shape the future of mid-size SUVs, with manufacturers striving to deliver vehicles that are not only reliable and practical but also environmentally friendly and technologically advanced. Automotive professionals must stay informed about these trends to provide the best possible service and advice to their customers.